An event I have regretfully still to attend for the first time is the opera at Verona’s Roman amphitheatre. I have, naturally, visited that exquisite city, the notorious setting of Shakespeare’s ‘Romeo and Juliet’, and have attended opera in another Roman ruin, the Baths of Caracalla: a production of Verdi’s ‘Aida’ complete with elephants and camels. That was way back in 1963 when I was a pubescent schoolboy. Fortunately today ‘Aida’ is represented without such exotica and is delivered as the truly intimate opera it is (once the grand ceremony of Act 2 is got through). Clearly, living rather near to Torre Del Lago, I have not missed out on going to a Puccini opera there. I forget how many times I have seen his unfinished chef d’oevre ‘Turandot’. (To read about a production I attended there go to https://longoio2.wordpress.com/2014/08/10/tantalizing-turandot-at-torre-del-lago-puccini/ and to visit the little palace where ‘Turandot’ grew up see my post at https://longoio2.wordpress.com/2016/02/10/where-turandot-grew-up/
Romeo and Juliet bring me to mind Zeffirelli’s forceful film which I first saw in 1968 during a particularly bleak winter in Milan. That film brought the star-crossed lovers Leonard Whiting and Olivia Hussey out of the then standard fusty theatricals bang into a contemporary teenage situation, as it should be.
Franco Zeffirelli was superb at producing operas – his direction of ‘La Traviata’ ranks supreme – and the combination of Verona’s ‘amfiteatro’ with the production of Bizet’s ‘Carmen’, shown on RAI 3 a couple of nights ago was enthralling. Clémentine Margaine was an excellent Carmen. Gilda Fiume sang Micaela. Brian Jagde was Don Josè, and Luca Micheletti the bullfighter Escamillo. Marco Armiliato conducted the Orchestra and Chorus of the Arena di Verona Foundation.

‘Carmen’ also reminds me of another recording of the opera, that conducted by Sir Georg Solti. In particular the scream the heroine launches when she exits from the tobacco factory where she works and lands in a fight is blood-curdling. Who was responsible for that superb shout? My wife, Sandra, who was involved in the production!

It is incredibly sad that Bizet never saw the moment when his masterpiece would conquer the world’s opera houses to become what has often been voted as the best-loved opera of all time. In this respect this morning I came across something I wrote regarding Bizet and his operas. For he DID write others besides from ‘Carmen’.

How many operas did Bizet compose? Carmen, The Pearl Fishers (currently at the London Coliseum in a revival of English National Opera’s much-praised production). That’s two, for starters.
But look through the catalogue of the composer’s works in Winton Dean’s book on the composer (J. M. Dent Master Musicians series) and there are thirty opera and operetta titles listed. What and where are the other twenty eight?
A closer read will show that, of the remaining twenty eight operas, only three were actually finished, performed in the composer’s lifetime and survive to the present day. They are Doctor Miracle, The Fair Maid of Perth, and Djamileh. Another completed operetta, Sol si re pif pan, is lost, probably destroyed after its performance in 1873.
Of these works Doctor Miracle is an operetta and Djamileh a one-acter. A further operetta, Don Procopio, only received its first performance in 1906. The other twenty three works are either projects, sketches, completions of operas by contemporaries or else have vanished. One project was based on Samuel Richardson’s Clarissa Harlowe, a subject eventually realised in Jonathan Harvey’s sensitive work premiered by English National Opera in 1990. Another, La Coupe du Roi de Thulé, which might have ranked second to Carmen in quality, sadly only survives as a few fragments thanks to the Widow Bizet’s habit of selling off pages from her husband’s manuscripts for much needed francs.
Another strange fact about the operas is that, with the exception of Djamileh, written in 1871, and Carmen, in 1873, Bizet’s surviving works in this genre were all composed before 1867. So what did he write between 1867 and 1871? Four years is a long time in the artistic career of a composer who lived only one year longer than Mozart, his great idol.
The fact is that Bizet was singularly unfortunate in obtaining both appropriate libretti and backers for his dramatic works. Moreover, he suffered a spiritual crisis in mid-career which sapped at his self-confidence. After the early perfection of the Symphony in C, written at the age of seventeen but only re-discovered and performed 80 years later, the composer genuinely doubted his ability to complete any project. “I am afraid of my return,” he writes in a letter of 1858. Furthermore, he had to find money to care for his mentally ill wife Genevieve Halevy (second daughter of his old teacher, and a relative of the librettist of Carmen) in addition to his burgeoning family. This meant that for much of his life Bizet was forced into the kind of hack work loathed by most musicians: transcriptions, arrangements, copy-making and giving piano lessons to spoilt brats.
Bizet was a natural genius whose first thoughts were usually his best. Of his lamentably short catalogue of finished compositions the least memorable works were written (and re-written) over a long period. The Roma symphony, for example, occupied the composer on and off for several years. His finest works, on the other hand, were, like the incidental music to Daudet’s play L’Arlesienne, put together in a matter of weeks.
To go back to our initial question: how many operas did Bizet write? Considering only the completed full-length works just two: The Fair Maid of Perth and The Pearl Fishers. Carmen is an opéra-comique, not an opera, since it has spoken dialogue. (The recitatives, composed after Bizet’s death by Guiraud in an attempt to turn it into an Opera, although skilful in their way, are discredited and unperformed now.)
One thing is certain, however: Bizet’s career as an opera composer began with a miracle, Doctor Miracle, performed when he was nineteen, and ended with another, Carmen, staged in 1875, the year of his premature death by undetermined causes, though that work’s sensational failure at its first performance must have had no little part to play in it.




























































